DoggieLawn vs PetSafe Pet Loo verdict
Real grass wins on feel, freshness & free time
If you want an indoor potty that feels like the outdoors and doesn't come with a cleaning schedule, DoggieLawn is the better pick. Your pup gets real grass, and you get a fresh lawn on your schedule with no turf to rinse and no urine container to empty.
The PetSafe Pet Loo is a well-made, reusable system, and it can cost less over time if you don't mind the upkeep. But PetSafe's own care guide calls for a daily rinse, a cleaner spray two to three times a week and a full wash every week. Many busy pet parents would rather toss a lawn and get on with their day.
Our pick
DoggieLawn
8.7 vs 6.4
Wins 5 of 6 rounds
DoggieLawn wins every round but one, with the widest gaps in real grass feel and cleanup effort. The Pet Loo keeps long-term reuse, since its base is built to be rinsed and used again.
- Real Grass Feel 10.0 vs 5.5
- Cleanup Effort 9.0 vs 5.0
- Grows With Your Dog 9.0 vs 6.0
Real grass vs synthetic turf dog potty at a glance
Two very different indoor potties
The Pet Loo, made by PetSafe, is a plastic base topped with a synthetic grass mat. Urine drains through the mat into a removable waste container underneath. DoggieLawn is a pad of real grass that you replace on a schedule. Here's the quick look.
The biggest difference is where the urine goes. On the Pet Loo it drains through synthetic turf into a waste container you empty, and on DoggieLawn the real grass soaks it up until the next lawn arrives.
DoggieLawn
From $34.85 per fresh lawn
Best for Pups who love real grass and owners who'd rather swap than scrub
- Real, hydroponically grown grass
- Arrives ready to use
- Old lawn goes in the trash or green bin
PetSafe Pet Loo
From $69.95 one time, plus supplies
Best for Owners who want a reusable unit and don't mind regular cleaning
- Synthetic grass mat on a plastic base
- 2 liter waste container to empty
- Daily rinse and a weekly full wash
Real grass vs synthetic turf dog potty
What your pup actually stands on
PetSafe describes the Pet Loo as a portable indoor and outdoor toilet for dogs, cats and small pets. Its synthetic grass mat sits on a reinforced plastic base, urine drains through into a removable waste container, and an optional Pee Pod lined with Wee Sponge powder turns the liquid into a gel for easier disposal. Solid waste gets picked up with a scooper or a bag.
DoggieLawn takes the other route: real grass, hydroponically grown on a farm in California. Because it's living grass, it smells and feels like the outdoors, and DoggieLawn finds that dogs recognize that smell and texture right away, which makes training feel more natural. The grass naturally absorbs liquid and helps neutralize odors, so there's no waste container to empty.
Synthetic turf can work. The American Kennel Club (AKC) notes that artificial turf works well for many puppies and dogs. But it's still a plastic mat, and keeping it fresh is your job, which is where the two options really pull apart.
Featured Product
Potty Training Fire Hydrant
A silicone pee post that gives leg lifters something to aim at on their DoggieLawn.
Got a leg lifter? PetSafe suggests setting a disposable cup in the middle of the Pet Loo as a target. On a DoggieLawn, the silicone Potty Training Fire Hydrant does the same job, and you can weigh it down with pebbles or sand so it stays put.
How to clean a Pet Loo vs a grass pad
The weekly chores, compared
Here's the Pet Loo routine, straight from PetSafe's product page. Every day, pour warm water over the grass to flush out extra urine. Two to three times a week, spray the unit and grass with PetSafe's Wee Care cleaner and let it dry. Once a week, spray it thoroughly, leave it for 5 to 10 minutes, remove the grass and wash the entire unit with a hose, shower or sink sprayer, then let it dry completely. The waste container holds 2 liters and gets emptied into your toilet or yard.
The DoggieLawn routine is shorter. Pick up poop with a bag as it happens. When your next lawn arrives, slip on the disposable gloves that come in every shipment, lift out the old pad and drop it in the trash or green compost bin.
One habit keeps your pup happy: water the grass only as needed. Most dogs would rather skip wet grass, DoggieLawn says, so a light splash is only worth it in hot weather or for a pup who doesn't mind.
DoggieLawn vs Pet Loo scores
Six scores, one clear winner
We scored both from 0 to 10 on six things that decide how an indoor potty fits into your week. Here's where each one lands, and why.
Cleanup effort is where your week changes most. These scores lean on PetSafe's own care guide for the Pet Loo's routine, and the Pet Loo earns its one win in long-term reuse.
Round 1
Real Grass Feel
DoggieLawn wins
DoggieLawn is living grass with a familiar smell and texture. The Pet Loo uses a synthetic grass mat.
Round 2
Cleanup Effort
DoggieLawn wins
PetSafe's care guide asks for a daily rinse, a spray two to three times a week and a weekly wash. DoggieLawn is swap and toss.
Round 3
Odor Control
DoggieLawn wins
Real grass helps neutralize odors and gets replaced fresh. The Pet Loo traps smells with a covered bin, Wee Sponge powder and regular cleaning.
Round 4
Upfront Cost
DoggieLawn wins
A DoggieLawn starts at $34.85 per lawn. The Pet Loo starts at $69.95 for the small size and $109.95 for the large.
Round 5
Grows With Your Dog
DoggieLawn wins
Change your DoggieLawn size or delivery timing anytime from your account. A Pet Loo is one fixed size once you buy it.
Round 6
Long-Term Reuse
Pet Loo wins
The Pet Loo wins here. Its base is built to be rinsed and reused, with replacement mats and Pee Pods sold separately.
DoggieLawn vs PetSafe Pet Loo comparison table
The details, side by side
Here's how DoggieLawn and the Pet Loo stack up on the practical details, from what's underfoot to what you pay.
Look at the cleaning routine and disposal rows side by side. One is a schedule of rinses, sprays and washes, and the other is a lawn you toss in the trash or compost when it's done.
| Feature | DoggieLawn | Pet Loo |
|---|---|---|
| Potty surface | Real, hydroponically grown grass | Synthetic grass mat |
| Where urine goes | Absorbed by the grass | Drains into a 2 liter container |
| Cleaning routine | Swap in each fresh lawn as it arrives | Daily rinse, weekly full wash |
| Disposal | Trash or green compost bin | Empty the container into a toilet or yard |
| Sizes | Five sizes, Standard to XXL | Small, medium and large |
| Rating on its own site | 4.9 out of 5 (10,361 reviews) | 4.3 out of 5 (73 reviews) |
| Price | From $34.85 per lawn | $69.95 to $109.95, plus supplies |
DoggieLawn & Pet Loo pros & cons
What you gain & what you give up
Here's the quick list for each one, so you can weigh the tradeoffs at a glance.
The Pet Loo's cons are all about upkeep: synthetic turf, a daily rinse and a container to empty. DoggieLawn's are about the subscription, a recurring delivery that ships only within the contiguous US.
DoggieLawn
Pros
- Real grass with a familiar smell and feel
- No turf to rinse and no container to empty
- Change size or delivery timing anytime
- Biodegradable and green-bin friendly
Cons
- A recurring delivery, not a one-time buy
- Best watered only as needed
- Ships only within the contiguous US
Pet Loo
Pros
- Sturdy, reusable plastic base
- Three sizes, from small to large breeds
- Works indoors, on patios and in RVs
- Covered waste bin helps trap smells
Cons
- Synthetic turf, not real grass
- Daily rinse plus a weekly full wash
- Waste container needs regular emptying
Choosing between DoggieLawn & the Pet Loo
Which one is right for you?
Choose DoggieLawn if you want your pup on real grass, if you're training a puppy who will also go outside, or if your week simply doesn't have room for a turf-washing routine. A new lawn shows up when you need it, you toss the old one, and that's the whole chore. You can change the size or delivery frequency, or skip, pause or cancel anytime from your account.
The Pet Loo can make sense if you'd rather buy once and reuse, and you're comfortable rinsing turf and emptying a container. PetSafe also designs it for smaller spaces like RVs, campers, apartments and patios, so it travels well.
If you've been looking for the Pet Loo, it's still a current product. As of October 2026, PetSafe sells it on its own website in small, medium and large sizes, priced from $69.95 to $109.95.
Switching from turf to real grass
- Set the grass where the Pet Loo used to be
- Offer it after waking, eating, drinking and play
- Reward your pup right after they go
- Keep the first week calm and consistent
Those potty times come from the AKC's housetraining advice, and Humane World for Animals (formerly the Humane Society of the United States) cautions that scolding accidents only makes pups fearful and slows progress. If you hit a snag, every DoggieLawn subscription includes free training help from an expert with 10+ years of experience.
DoggieLawn vs PetSafe Pet Loo FAQ
Your questions, answered
Pet Loo owners thinking about a switch usually ask these four questions.
Is the PetSafe Pet Loo Real Grass?
No. According to PetSafe, the Pet Loo uses a synthetic grass mat on a reinforced plastic base, and urine drains through the mat into a removable waste container. If you want real grass, DoggieLawn pads are living, hydroponically grown grass.
How Do You Clean a Pet Loo?
PetSafe recommends pouring warm water over the grass daily, spraying the unit with its Wee Care cleaner two to three times a week, and once a week removing the grass and washing the whole unit with a hose, shower or sink sprayer, then letting it dry completely.
Does Real Grass Smell Better Than Synthetic Turf?
Real grass helps neutralize odors naturally, and with DoggieLawn a fresh lawn arrives on your schedule, so there's no scrubbing the same mat. PetSafe pairs the Pet Loo with a covered waste bin, Wee Sponge powder and an enzyme cleaner to keep smells down.
Can My Dog Switch from a Pet Loo to DoggieLawn?
Usually, yes. Set the DoggieLawn where the Pet Loo used to be, take your pup to it at their usual potty times and praise them right after they go. A spritz of DoggieLawn's Potty Training Boost can help in the first days, and subscribers get free 1-on-1 training calls.
Real grass vs fake grass articles
More from the DoggieLawn blog
